Diet and nutritionStudies updated this monthHimalayan salt or Kłodawa salt?! The truth about pink salt
Sources: 8 · Article: 7 207 characters ↓
What do Natural Therapy Specialists write?
Jerzy Zięba
Kłodawa salt comes from the same deposit as Himalayan salt, and its pink color is not caused by dye.
„It is this salt that comes from the same deposit as the famous Himalayan salt. Kłodawa salt is sometimes white and sometimes pink, but that is not because someone—as in some cases with Himalayan salt—bought refined salt, added dye, and sold it as Himalayan salt.”To właśnie ona pochodzi z takiego samego złoża, jak słynna sól himalajska. Sól kłodawska czasami jest biała a czasami różowa, ale to nie wynika z tego, że – jak w niektórych przypadkach soli himalajskiej – ktoś kupił sól rafinowaną, dodał barwnika i sprzedaje ją jako sól himalajską.
Jerzy Zięba
Jerzy Zięba considers sea salt the healthiest, provided it has not been processed and has retained what occurs naturally.
„The healthiest salt for people comes from the sea, but only if it has not been processed in any way—in other words, if it is as it occurs in nature. Whenever people start trying to improve on nature, they always spoil something. And that is exactly what happens, because sea salt is subjected to so-called refining, or purification, which removes everything that was in the salt, leaving only pure sodium chloride.”Najzdrowsza dla człowieka sól pochodzi z morza, ale jest to tylko taka sól, której nie poddano jakiemukolwiek przetwarzaniu, a więc taka, jaka występuje w naturze. Kiedy człowiek zaczyna poprawiać naturę to zawsze coś zepsuje. No i psuje, ponieważ sól morską poddaje się tak zwanej rafinacji, czyli oczyszczaniu ze wszystkiego co tylko w tej soli się znajdowało, tak aby pozostał czysty chlorek sodu.
Jerzy Zięba
According to Jerzy Zięba, refining removes minerals and other substances from salt that the author considers important for health.
„These substances are found in natural sea salt, but during refining they are thrown away, and we, the customers, are given just one substance: sodium chloride! That is why this kind of salt does not serve its purpose, and consuming it can indeed be harmful to people.”Tego rodzaju substancje znajdują się właśnie w naturalnej soli morskiej, ale w procesie rafinacji te substancje wyrzucono na śmietnik, a nam, klientom, podano tylko jedną substancję, którą jest chlorek sodu! Dlatego właśnie tego typu sól nie spełnia swojej roli i rzeczywiście jej spożycie może być dla człowieka szkodliwe.
Henryk Różański
Henryk Różański attributes considerable flavor and health value to seasonings containing sea salt or unrefined salts rich in elements.
„Salt stimulates the secretion of saliva and increases the sensitivity of taste receptors. Seasonings containing sea salt, as well as unrefined salts with a high content of bioelements (micro- and ultra-elements, such as fluorine, manganese, and molybdenum), have considerable flavor and health value.”Sól pobudza wydzielanie śliny i zwiększa wrażliwość receptorów smaku. Dużą wartość smakowo-zdrowotną mają przyprawy zawierające sól morską oraz sole nieoczyszczane z dużą domieszką biopierwiastków (mikro- i utraelementów, np. fluoru, manganu, molibdenu).
Jerzy Zięba
Jerzy Zięba describes white table salt as almost pure sodium chloride and considers it harmful to the body.
„The salt we buy in the supermarket, the lovely, bright-white kind, is really just sodium chloride. It is useless and even harmful to the human body. The question will immediately arise: what about so-called iodized salt? The answer: nothing changes, because it is the same thing.”Sól, którą kupujemy w supermarkecie, ta śliczna, bielutka, to właściwie tylko sam chlorek sodu. Jest ona bezużyteczna i wręcz dla organizmu człowieka szkodliwa. Natychmiast padnie pytanie: a co z tak zwaną solą jodowaną? Odpowiedź: a nic, bo jest to to samo.
Prof. Klaus F. Kopp
Prof. Klaus F. Kopp distinguishes table salt from sodium bicarbonate and writes that salt can be harmful in certain situations.
„NaCl = Salt may indeed be harmful or “bad” in certain situations.
Sodium bicarbonate, NaHCO3, is the natural physiological buffer in the mammalian organism, and if it is substituted at normal concentrations it may be considered “good”. However, excessive intake of 100 grams of sodium bicarbonate is certainly not advisable and would require medical treatment.”NaCl = Salt may indeed be harmful or “bad” in certain situations.
Sodium Bicarbonate, NaHCO3, is the natural physiological buffer in the mammalian organism and and if it is substituted at normal concentrations it may be considered as “good”. However, the excessive intake of 100 Gram of Sodium Bicarbonate is certainly not advisable and would require medical treatment.
Jerzy Zięba
Jerzy Zięba believes that the right kind of salt is necessary for the body and criticizes low-salt diets.
„So good, appropriate salt is essential for the proper functioning of the human body. For this reason, all kinds of low-salt diets are harmful to people. The “salt phobia” spread by the media has led many people to boast that they hardly use any salt at all.”Tak więc dobra, właściwa sól jest produktem niezbędnym dla prawidłowego funkcjonowania organizmu człowieka. Z tego powodu właśnie wszelkiego rodzaju diety nisko solne są dla człowieka szkodliwe. Rozpowszechniana przez media „solofobia” spowodowała, że wiele osób chwali się tym, że soli właściwie wcale nie używa.
Prof. Klaus F. Kopp
Prof. Klaus F. Kopp warns against excessive salt consumption, especially by people with heart or kidney disease or high blood pressure, and by pregnant women.
„This unfortunately makes confusion with other sodium salts, especially sodium bicarbonate, inevitable. But since nobody should eat too much salt—especially not people with heart or kidney disease or high blood pressure, nor pregnant women—in other words, nobody at all, desperate efforts are made to keep the total sodium content of mineral waters, various foods, and diet products as low as possible and to remove or reduce it at considerable expense, just to make sure no harm is done.”Dadurch ist die Verwechslung mit anderen Natrium-Salzen leider vor allem mit Natrium-Bikarbonat vorprogrammiert Da aber niemand zu viel Salz essen soll, schon gar nicht Herz-, Nieren- oder Hochdruck-Kranke, auch nicht Schwangere, d.h. gar niemand, - wird verzweifelt versucht, den gesamten Natrium-Gehalt von Mineralwässern oder verschiedenen Nahrungsmitteln oder Diätetika, so niedrig wie möglich zu halten und kostenaufwendig zu entfernen oder zu reduzieren, damit ja nur kein Schaden entsteht.
What does scientific research from PubMed · Europe PMC say?
We selected 1 studies with the best, positive results. This is a selection, not a full review of all research.
Total number of studies on this topic in PubMed: 47.
Aim of the study: Iodized table salt provides iodide that is essential for health. However, during cooking, we found that chloramine residuals in tap water can react with iodide in table salt and organic matter in pasta to form iodinated disinfection byproducts (I-DBPs).
Results: The calculated cytotoxicity and genotoxicity of I-THMs in the pasta and cooking water were 126 and 18 times higher, respectively, than in the corresponding chloraminated tap water. However, when the cooked pasta was separated (strained) from the pasta water, chlorodiiodomethane was the dominant I-THM, and lower levels of total I-THMs (30% of the I-THMs remained) and calculated toxicity were observed. This study highlights an overlooked source of exposure to toxic I-DBPs. At the same time, I-DBP formation can be avoided by boiling pasta without a lid and adding iodized salt after cooking.
Money for the studynot stated
Do the authors have ties to companies?not stated
Did a manufacturer help with the study?unknown
Type of studyother
“Not stated” does not mean nobody paid — the database does not always record it.
What do orthomolecular medicine doctors write?
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service
„I attribute the calming of my heart rate (now 55–60 bpm) primarily to magnesium, potassium, taurine, and adequate salt intake, which I have based on the recommendations of Brownstein, “Salt Your Way to Health” [6], and Dinicolantonio, “The Salt Fix” [7], and monitored by measuring sodium levels. My exercise and meditation sessions certainly also played a part. I did not take the beta blockers prescribed to relieve my heart “as part of heart failure therapy”. For most individuals, eating plentiful servings of vegetables and fruits can provide adequate potassium.”I attribute the calming of the heart rate (now 55 - 60 bpm) primarily to magnesium, potassium, taurine and an adequate salt intake, which I have based on the recommendations of Brownstein "Salt Your Way to Health" [6] and Dinicolantonio "The Salt Fix" [7], controlled by measuring the sodium level. My exercise and meditation sessions certainly also played a part. I did not take the beta blockers prescribed to relieve my heart "as part of heart failure therapy". For most individuals, eating plentiful servings of vegetables and fruits can provide adequate potassium.
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service
„[Strategy for reducing salt consumption in the population.] Report IS-0339, Norwegian Directorate of Health, Oslo, October 2011. Cordain L. Evolutionary Aspects of Diet: Old Genes, New Fuels.”[Strategy for reduction of the salt consumption in the population.] Rapport IS-0339, Helsedirektoratet, Oslo, oktober 2011 [Report, Directorate of Health, October 2011]. Cordain L. Evolutionary Aspects of Diet: Old Genes, New Fuels.
Orthomolecular Medicine News Service
„In addition to oral supplements (we like magnesium citrate), we also take Epsom salt baths twice a week. Can you get too much sodium from sodium ascorbate vitamin C? Cardiologist Thomas E. Personally speaking, when I or my children are getting a significant amount of sodium as sodium ascorbate, we make a point of eating lots of fruits and vegetables and drinking lots of fresh, raw, homemade vegetable juice (for potassium). We also make a point of getting plenty of magnesium through oral supplements and Epsom salt baths.”In addition to oral supplements (we like magnesium citrate), we also take Epsom salt baths twice a week. Can you get too much sodium from sodium ascorbate vitamin C? Cardiologist Thomas E. Personally speaking, when I or my children are getting a significant amount of sodium as sodium ascorbate we make a point to eat lots of fruits and veggies and drink lots of fresh raw homemade veggie juice (for potassium). We also make a point to get plenty of magnesium via oral supplements and Epsom salt baths.
Pisaczek does not judge who is right. It shows what was written and where to read it. Every sentence above has its source.